She Announces She's Singing Simon's Favorite Song. His Comeback Brings On Judge's Accusation

It's hard to impress Simon Cowell. He's one of the most notoriously harsh judges on reality television, but when he likes something, he makes it very clear!

So when X Factor contestant Caitlyn Vanbeck stepped on the stage and shared that she was going to sing "Rise Up" by Andra Day, Simon's face lit up. It's a little-known fact that "Rise Up" is one of his favorite songs and he was curious to see how this young lady would do during her performance!